VLC is the better choice for converting MP4 to AVI because current HandBrake releases do not export AVI. HandBrake is excellent for shrinking files and making clean MP4, MKV, or WebM copies, but it is not the right tool when the final file must be .avi. MP4 remains more common for modern playback; H.264 video has broad browser support, listed at over 96% global usage coverage by Can I use [source: Can I use]. Still, AVI shows up in older CCTV systems, legacy Windows software, car media players, and classroom projectors that refuse to behave.
TLDR: For a real MP4 to AVI conversion, VLC is the practical pick. HandBrake should be used only if the user can accept MP4, MKV, or WebM instead of AVI. For example, a school technician converting 40 short MP4 clips for an older projector may finish the job in VLC without installing extra tools, while HandBrake would force a different output format. Expect VLC to feel a bit clunky, but it gets the AVI file made.
VLC vs. HandBrake at a Glance
- Best for AVI output: VLC
- Best for compression quality: HandBrake
- Best for batch encoding: HandBrake, if AVI is not required
- Best for older devices: VLC, because it can create AVI files
- Best for beginners: VLC for simple AVI jobs, HandBrake for polished MP4 jobs
The main difference is simple. VLC is both a media player and a converter. It can output AVI through its conversion profile settings. HandBrake is a video transcoder, but its modern output options are limited to containers such as MP4, MKV, and WebM, as shown in its own documentation [source: HandBrake].
That one detail saves a lot of wasted time. It drives people mad when HandBrake is installed, the MP4 is loaded, the settings are adjusted, and then AVI is nowhere in the save options. Nothing is broken. HandBrake just does not work that way anymore.
How VLC Converts MP4 to AVI
VLC can convert MP4 to AVI without much setup. It is free, works on Windows, macOS, and Linux, and supports many codecs. The interface is not pretty, but it is direct enough once the right menu is found.
- Open VLC Media Player.
- Go to Media, then choose Convert / Save.
- Click Add and select the MP4 file.
- Press Convert / Save.
- Open the Profile menu.
- Choose an AVI profile, or create one with AVI as the encapsulation format.
- Pick video and audio codecs. Common choices include MPEG-4 video and MP3 audio.
- Select the destination folder and name the file with the .avi extension.
- Click Start.
The catch is that VLC’s profiles can be awkward. A user may need to create a new profile manually if AVI does not appear in the default list. That adds roughly a minute or two to the task, which feels silly for such a basic conversion.
Best VLC Settings for MP4 to AVI
There is no perfect AVI setting for every device. AVI is only a container. The video and audio codecs inside it matter just as much.
- For old Windows software: MPEG-4 video with MP3 audio is usually safe.
- For DVD-era players: DIVX or XVID may work better, if available.
- For smaller files: lower the bitrate, but expect weaker image quality.
- For fewer playback issues: keep the original frame rate.
If the source MP4 is 1080p and the target hardware is old, a 720p AVI may be a smarter choice. The file is smaller, the processor works less, and playback is less likely to stutter.
What HandBrake Does Instead
HandBrake is still a great converter. It just solves a different problem. It is made for controlled encoding, preset-based compression, subtitle handling, chapter support, and high-quality MP4 or MKV exports.
A user who wants a smaller MP4 from a huge phone recording should pick HandBrake. A user who wants an AVI file for an old security system should not.
HandBrake is often better when the goal is:
- Reducing file size while keeping good quality.
- Converting large videos for phones or tablets.
- Using presets for YouTube, Apple devices, Roku, or Android playback.
- Cleaning up video libraries into modern formats.
Honestly, it feels odd that many “MP4 to AVI” guides still mention HandBrake as if AVI were a normal export option. For current versions, that advice sends users in circles.
Quality, Speed, and File Size
VLC is convenient, but it is not always the cleanest encoder. Its output can be fine for casual use, presentations, classroom playback, or old hardware. For high-quality archiving, it is not the first pick.
HandBrake usually gives better control over quality. Its Constant Quality slider, presets, filters, cropping tools, and preview options are more refined. If the output can be MP4 or MKV, HandBrake usually wins on polish.
AVI files can also become large. An MP4 file that is 500 MB may turn into an AVI file that is 700 MB, 1 GB, or more, depending on the codec and bitrate. That surprises many users. AVI is older, and it does not always store modern compression as neatly as MP4.
When VLC Is the Right Choice
VLC is the right tool when the final filename must end in .avi. That may be due to strict software rules, not personal preference.
Common cases include:
- Older projector systems in schools or meeting rooms.
- CCTV review software that imports only AVI clips.
- Legacy Windows applications used by clinics, labs, or local offices.
- Car stereos or TV USB ports with limited format support.
In those cases, VLC is not glamorous. It is just useful. The user gets a file that old software is more likely to accept.
When HandBrake Is the Better Choice
HandBrake is the better choice when AVI is not a hard requirement. It is especially useful when the user wants a modern file that is smaller, cleaner, and easier to share.
For example, a 2 GB phone video can often be compressed into a much smaller MP4 with little visible loss, depending on the settings. HandBrake’s presets make that process easier than VLC’s profile system. It also gives more predictable results across many files.
Image not found in postmetaRecommended Workflow
The smartest workflow depends on the final device.
- If AVI is required: use VLC first.
- If quality control matters more than AVI: use HandBrake and export MP4 or MKV.
- If VLC’s AVI does not play: try another codec inside VLC, such as MPEG-4 video with MP3 audio.
- If many AVI files are needed: consider a tool built for batch AVI conversion, because VLC batch work is not pleasant.
For most people, the decision is quick. VLC converts MP4 to AVI. HandBrake does not serve that exact job in current versions. HandBrake remains the better encoder for modern formats, but VLC wins the AVI fight by default.
FAQ
Can HandBrake convert MP4 to AVI?
No. Current HandBrake versions do not export AVI. They focus on MP4, MKV, and WebM containers.
Can VLC convert MP4 to AVI for free?
Yes. VLC is free and can convert MP4 files into AVI through the Convert / Save menu.
Why does the converted AVI file not play?
The device may support AVI but reject the codec inside it. Trying MPEG-4 video with MP3 audio often helps with older systems.
Will converting MP4 to AVI improve quality?
No. Conversion cannot add lost detail. It may keep similar quality, but it can also create quality loss if the bitrate is too low.
Is AVI better than MP4?
Not usually. MP4 is better for modern sharing, streaming, and device support. AVI is mainly useful for older software and hardware.
Which tool is faster?
VLC can be faster for a simple one-file AVI conversion. HandBrake may be faster and cleaner for repeated MP4 or MKV encoding tasks, especially with presets.
